What if membership was not about unlimited access?
The default membership model in most service businesses is simple: pay a monthly fee, use the service as much as you want. It is easy to sell. It is easy to understand. And it creates a structural margin problem that gets worse as your business grows.
Every unlimited member who uses the service above the breakeven threshold is costing you money. The more successful your marketing is at attracting engaged, high-frequency users, the more your margins compress. The incentive structure is backwards: your best, most loyal customers are your least profitable.
Costco solved this problem decades ago. The membership fee is not payment for products. It is payment for access to better pricing. The actual goods are sold at near-cost. The business model is the fee, not the transaction.
Applied to service businesses, this means separating the access component from the usage component. The membership fee buys the right to member-only pricing on each service visit. The operator captures margin on both the access fee and the per-use revenue. The customer gets a meaningfully better price per visit than a non-member, which justifies the membership. And the operator's margins no longer deteriorate with higher usage.
The Costco model is not right for every operator or every market. It works best when per-service costs are meaningful (not negligible), when there is a wide range of usage frequency across the member base, when the operator is competing against both high-volume discount and premium competitors, and when the current unlimited model is producing a significant number of members whose usage exceeds the margin threshold.
It also works as a complementary tier alongside traditional unlimited plans, creating a lower barrier to entry for price-sensitive customers who want member benefits without committing to a high monthly fee.
The math question: What percentage of your unlimited members use the service more than the breakeven number of times per month? If it is above 30%, you have a structural margin problem that will compound as you grow. The Costco model addresses it at the architecture level.
This play examines usage frequency distribution, per-service cost at the plan level, breakeven thresholds by tier, and the revenue impact of hybrid pricing models. The output is a scenario analysis showing how access-fee-plus-per-use compares to the current unlimited structure.
30 minutes. I will tell you if there is a pricing opportunity worth pursuing.
Book a Pricing Review